Welcome to Pudgie's Pizza Pasta & Subs
Pudgie's Pizza Pasta & Subs, located at 520 N Main St in Canandaigua, NY, is a beloved local eatery known for its delicious pizza, pasta, and subs. With a reputation for outstanding food quality, Pudgie's offers a variety of options including vegetarian slices and enticing daily specials, like two slices of cheese pizza paired with a refreshing Coke. Customers rave about the freshly made dishes and generous portions, particularly the mild barbecue wings and signature Pudgie’s Burger. While the unique decor featuring taxidermy sparks mixed reactions, the warm, family-run atmosphere makes it a go-to spot for casual dining, takeout, and delivery.
-
520 N Main St, Canandaigua, NY 14424, United States520 N Main St, Canandaigua, NY 14424, United States Hotline: +1 585-394-6720
Welcome to Pudgie's Pizza Pasta & Subs, your go-to destination for flavorful dishes that satisfy every craving. Nestled in the heart of Canandaigua, NY at 520 N Main St, Pudgie's is a beloved spot where the atmosphere is as laid-back as the menu is diverse. Whether you fancy a cold sub, crispy fried treat, or a pie that rivals the best in New York, Pudgie’s offers a delightful mix of flavors that keeps locals and visitors alike coming back for more.
The menu boasts a tantalizing array of cold subs, featuring fan favorites like the Super Sub and Italian Sub. Each is made with fresh, quality ingredients and served on artisan bread that really elevates the overall experience. For those who prefer something crispy, their offerings from the fryer, like mozzarella sticks and onion rings, bring a satisfying crunch that perfectly complements any meal. And let’s not forget about the classic combination of two slices of cheese pizza and a 16 oz. soda, which boasts both convenience and flavor in every bite.
Reviews from satisfied patrons highlight Pudgie’s as a cornerstone of the community, with quotes like “Pudgies rivals with the top pizza places in the state of New York” underscoring its stellar reputation. The pizza crust is described as “spot on,” while the fresh ingredients and delicious sauce contribute to a truly remarkable experience. There’s a reason some say it’s the “top dog in the neighborhood.”
For those venturing beyond pizza, the staff recommends trying the Pudgie’s Burger, praised for its generous size and mouth-watering flavor. It's clear that everything served at Pudgie’s is crafted with care, making it an excellent choice for casual dining.
While some visitors may initially find the eclectic decor—specifically the unique collection of taxidermy on display—a bit jarring, many appreciate the character and charm it adds to the restaurant. As one customer noted, while it’s a bit unconventional for a pizza place, the atmosphere contributes to the overall experience.
If you're in search of a casual, family-friendly spot that focuses on great food at fair prices, look no further than Pudgie's Pizza Pasta & Subs. Whether you decide to dine in or opt for takeout, you’re guaranteed a meal that’s not only delicious but also provides a sense of community. So grab your friends and family, or swing by for a solo visit, and make sure to savor what Pudgie’s has to offer.
Pudgie's is always amazing, and we were so happy to find another location! The service was good - we found the stash of spice shakers ourselves over by the dining room entrance instead of on our tables, which was something we had to figure out, I guess. And I have never seen such a collection of taxidermy before.....kinda odd...still processing that....
Of course I got the mild barbecue wings and I ate in which was a great experience. It's crazy that 20 wings were 30 but I will pay it because I love the wings.
Ate here one time over the summer with my 5 year old. The stuff on the walls is wayyy strange for a pizza place. But the pizza was like every other pudgies
Pudgies rivals with the top pizza places in the state of New York. This is an excellent pizzeria. The crust, the sauce ,the cheese is spot on. We are originally from Buffalo and I’m super happy that we have a Great go-to place for pizza. Canadaigua has very good pizza, but Pudgies does stand out as top dog in the neighborhood. Try the Pudgie’s Burger, it’s huge and absolutely delicious.! This is a normal hang out, family run business. If you’re looking for fancy pants, you’re not going to get it, if you’re looking for excellent food at a fair price, you found the spot! Eat in, Take out, Delivery.
This was my first visit - the Sub was very good and the bread is so fresh and tasty too! The atmosphere I placed a 3 rating because of all the "Dead Animals" that have been placed around the building - it was overwhelming for a first time visit. The collection was amazing - from all over the world, but maybe not appropriate to have so many dead animals in restaurant setting. But will definitely visit again and maybe take the food with me.
I've been going to pudgies quite often. It is the best pizza. But last night was exceptional. My cousin had come over for a while. Shall we say a pajama party? We had a huge Stromboli and a great big sub. Let's just say we still have lunch and dinner for today. The taste was exceptional and the sub was just like they t used to be not some big fat piece of bread with two skinny pieces of me at .. general I just eat their pizza because the sauce is real sauce and you actually get enough cheese without having to ask for extra. I'll be ordering other things now too. They have delivery which is wonderful and the place is spotless
Got pizza and wings to go. The wings were awesome and the pizza was delicious!
Ordered baked ziti with meatballs ; pasta was very good; nice and clean dining room; service was excellent;